Showing posts with label race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label race. Show all posts
Sunday, September 20, 2015
By now I'm sure everyone has heard the tale of Ahmed Mohamed, the teenager who was put in handcuffs for bringing his homemade clock to school. This incident is a shameful example of predjudice getting out of hand, but has luckily turned out for the better for Ahmed in all the support he has found following his suspension. Since the story has spread, a lot of questions have been asked over the scenario. Did President Obama really need to get involved? Does the clock work? Does Sarah Palin really still believe that it's "more than a clock?" However, the one that I've read above any other is:
"Whould this have happebed if he was white?"
I read a pretty interesting article concerning this on The New York Post.
While I don't agree with the claim of this whole story being a "False, convient tale of racism" I do think the author's questions pose for a compelling conversation. Is the issue bias? Or is it something else?
In my opinion, it is difficult to deny that Islamophobia had a minor (if not major) role in Amed's arrest and suspension. However, I have to admit, when I first heard the story, my mind immediately went to an event that happened in my own community this past Wednesday, when a portion of the freeway was shutdown for an hour because of a cooler on the side of the road.
The New York Post article also rattles off some examples of overeactions to certain, unthreatening behavors in schools. Some students mentioned are white, some are not.
We can all agree that the reactions are extreme, we can all agree that the way they were handeled completely wrong, but what about the source of the behavior? From what illness is this a sympotom of?
When I play this out as happening at my old high school, which was predominantly white, I can very easily see a student proudly showing off his clock, and security thinking nothing of it, but at the same time, I can't rule out the possibility of the situation getting out of hand in the same way as it did for Ahmed, because I know it happenes all the time.
So, would this have happened to one of Ahmed's white classmates had they brought in a clock?
It's hard to say, but I think the greatest issue that's floated to the top of this entire ordeal is society's knee-jerk reaction to look for something to roll our eyes at, rather than allowing it to motivate us to try for something better. It always has to be dilluded by some debate. What were the administrators who called the police thinking? What was the racist-to-non-racist ratio? Who knows? Who cares?
It was another line added to the sad song of discrimination that too many minorities hear thanks to society's branding of all non-whites as violent and that's should matter.
It should have stopped before Treyvon.
It should have stopped before Tamir.
It should stopped before Ahmed.
How many more children need to fall victim before we admit that yes, racism is a problem, racism is the problem? I fear for a country that keeps asking why white kids aren't getting free white house tours instead of why black kids are getting shot.
But that's just me. Like I said before, I think this topic provides for some really, really compelling discussion, so for anybody reading this, I am personally challanging you to get out of your comfort zone and to share your opinion. What was your reaction to the story when you first heard it? What connections did you make? What do you think is the greater issue? Please, contribute below!
"Whould this have happebed if he was white?"
I read a pretty interesting article concerning this on The New York Post.
While I don't agree with the claim of this whole story being a "False, convient tale of racism" I do think the author's questions pose for a compelling conversation. Is the issue bias? Or is it something else?
In my opinion, it is difficult to deny that Islamophobia had a minor (if not major) role in Amed's arrest and suspension. However, I have to admit, when I first heard the story, my mind immediately went to an event that happened in my own community this past Wednesday, when a portion of the freeway was shutdown for an hour because of a cooler on the side of the road.
The New York Post article also rattles off some examples of overeactions to certain, unthreatening behavors in schools. Some students mentioned are white, some are not.
We can all agree that the reactions are extreme, we can all agree that the way they were handeled completely wrong, but what about the source of the behavior? From what illness is this a sympotom of?
When I play this out as happening at my old high school, which was predominantly white, I can very easily see a student proudly showing off his clock, and security thinking nothing of it, but at the same time, I can't rule out the possibility of the situation getting out of hand in the same way as it did for Ahmed, because I know it happenes all the time.
So, would this have happened to one of Ahmed's white classmates had they brought in a clock?
It's hard to say, but I think the greatest issue that's floated to the top of this entire ordeal is society's knee-jerk reaction to look for something to roll our eyes at, rather than allowing it to motivate us to try for something better. It always has to be dilluded by some debate. What were the administrators who called the police thinking? What was the racist-to-non-racist ratio? Who knows? Who cares?
It was another line added to the sad song of discrimination that too many minorities hear thanks to society's branding of all non-whites as violent and that's should matter.
It should have stopped before Treyvon.
It should have stopped before Tamir.
It should stopped before Ahmed.
How many more children need to fall victim before we admit that yes, racism is a problem, racism is the problem? I fear for a country that keeps asking why white kids aren't getting free white house tours instead of why black kids are getting shot.
But that's just me. Like I said before, I think this topic provides for some really, really compelling discussion, so for anybody reading this, I am personally challanging you to get out of your comfort zone and to share your opinion. What was your reaction to the story when you first heard it? What connections did you make? What do you think is the greater issue? Please, contribute below!
Sunday, September 13, 2015
A lot of the posts on this blog are based off of articles on other social justice websites. This week, i decided it was time for a change. I searched through my favorite websites, Psychology Today, for some insight on unconscious bias and what I found was an article that both shocked and impressed me.
Check it out here.
Dr. Mikhail Lyubansky expands on some issues outlined in a 2012 W.K Kellogg Foundation panel on "Unconscious Bias and Race." The issue is introduced with the horrifying study that revealed that Doctors actually treat patients different based on the color of their skin. They give them less pain medication, they're more reluctant to do strenuous procedures on them, and more likely to perform less desirable solutions like lower -body amputations for diabetics.
With data like this, both Lyubansky and panelists argue, it is impossible to deny that racial bias exists, and yet so few are willing to admit that unconscious bias is an issue, that racism is just a left-wing urban legend.
Psychologists argue that this bias is nothing to be ashamed of. Our brains naturally categorize everyday items into groups to make more sense of them, and the very same applies when it comes to people. But just because it's normal, doesn't mean it's okay. The longer the biases go unknown, the more harmful they can be, because the deeper they become ingrained into one's logic.
My favorite point was the following:
“There are three types of not knowing,”[John Powell, director of the Haas Center for Diversity and Inclusion and Robert D. Haas Chancellor’s Chair in Equity and Inclusion at the University of California Berkeley] explained: 1. What we can’t know, like how many neurons are firing at any given moment, 2. What we don’t care to know, like the color of the car we pass at a particular intersection, and 3. What we don’t want to know. When we talk about racism, we usually talk about #2 and #3, and those are important conversations to be having. We all need to care. We all need to want to know. But #1 is important as well."The article very prophetically describes a series of repercussions for unchecked bias that we are seeing here today. It's a pretty old piece, but overall, I think it's a good read because it goes over a lot of points that should made included into the conversation of unconscious bias, many of which weren't even mentioned in this blog post.
So the real question is, do you disagree? What stuck out to you?
Sunday, September 6, 2015
On 7:30 PM by Unknown in class, gender, LGBTQIA, linguistic, race, Rachel Sondgeroth, religion, solutions No comments
Privilege. I have it. You have it. Now what?
I've come to realize that I've drilled the importance of self-reflection into this blog, but not once have I described what self-reflection is, or what it looks like in the context of privilege. I'm going to try to fix that as best as I can.
Self-reflection, in layman's terms, is "meditation or serious thought about one's character, actions, and motives." It's taking a moment in your life to pause and critically contemplate the nature of your life, your self, and your actions. In a culture where we are all about self-validation, all about instant gratification, and life is constantly on the go, go, go, we have reached a destitute poverty of self-reflectors. Its gotten to a point where we don't even know what it looks like anymore. We don't even know where to begin.
Is self-reflecting self questioning?
Is it investigating? Excavating?
How long does it take?
Ten minutes?
Ten years?
I think the answer varies from person to person, but reflection in the context of privilege, in my opinion, is mostly based on observations that lead to an irreversible sort of awareness. It's an everlasting process. With different experiences, you become aware of different kinds of privilege. For example, I'd never really thought of able-bodied privilege until I started writing for this blog.
The real challenge comes when we start to deny the privilege that we have discovered, when we blow off multiple observations we've made as irrelevant to the conversation of unconscious bias.
A great example of the self-reflection process can be read in this article from the Huffington Post.
Gloria Atanmo exemplifies what it is to critically dissect observed disparities and sort them into privileges she has, many of which (such as African-American Privilege) she'd never consider a privilege previously .
Self-reflection varies on the person of course. What is reflection to me, to Atanmo, or her editor, could be entirely different from somebody else's "aha!" moment in privilege.
So what is self-reflection to you? Have you had any big "aha" moments worth that completely shifted your understanding of privilege?
Feel free to share in the comments below!
Sunday, August 30, 2015
And the Moonman for Best Hip Hop video goes to.. #VMAs http://t.co/SWRN5MPOOT
— MTV (@MTV) August 31, 2015
Nicki
Manaj's acceptance video has been a buzz all throughout social media
for the past few days. Her firm, assertive stance on white
artists winning awards by appropriating black artists' styles has
earned her a title as a revered voice of reason in the music
industry: a beacon of light. Manaj further inspired fans on stage at
the VMA's, where she called host Miley Cyrus out for her
tone-policing comments in a recent Time interview where
she claimed that Manaj was hurting her cause by not being
"polite."
As
awesome as it was, the speech was the end all to a greater issue. Not
to cultural appropriation, and especially not to tone-policing: an
issue that remains a huge threat to oppressed peoples outside of the
pop culture scope. However, as Maisha
Z. Johnson points out in a recent Everyday
Feminism article,
the whole ordeal does provide an important lesson to be learned, and
creates an ample opportunity to those blinded by their
bias to step forward and educate themselves.
Check out the article here.
Post
your thoughts in the comments below.
Sunday, June 21, 2015
It's no secret that women, particularly women in color, face the brunt of significant bias in their careers. But you'll be shocked to know the extent of it. According to a study by the Harvard Business Review, which included 557 surveys and 67 in-depth interviews from women in science, female scientists find that they constantly have to "prove" themselves to male co-workers. Prejudice fills these labs like a hot, sticky fog, causing women to struggle not only in maintaining respect, but preserving their passions.
According to this study, there are 5 types of Bias most women in STEM have in common.
1. Prove-It-Again:
People take Women's word for it when they insist that they are competent enough to do their jobs. Not only do they have to prove themselves over and over, but they often need more evidence to prove their points than male colleges.
2. The Gender-Role Tightrope:
Women can't act too feminine or they won't be respected, but at the same time, they can't be too masculine or they'll be considered "unlikable"
3. The Maternal Wall
Women are frequently questioned and expected to start families and, if they do, they are often pressured by co-workers to work less hours so that they can take care of their children.
4. Tug-of-War
While women generally support each other in the work place, others report that they feel as if they are competing for the "women's spot" in the workplace.
5. Isolation
This one is specific to women of color, who feel as if engaging with others socially takes away from their authority. In other cases, they find themselves being excluded from things because they think they'll be uncomfortable as the only minority in the group.
In addition to this, many women of color reported people being completely open and expectant to racial stereotypes, one black biologist reported being asked by an administrator if any of her family was "into drugs or in jail" while several Latinas claimed to overhear the stereotype of Hispanics being lazy. What's even worse, many of these minorities have reported to have been mistaken for janitorial or administrative staff.
This shows the sheer impact of bias. So many assume that making these assumptions is harmless, but the truth is, they hurt. And when people are faced with these comments and assumptions on a day-to-day basis, it goes from being a nuisance to a hostile workplace.Gender and Racial bias is driving women out of a field that we desperately need more people in. It's yet another reason why we must she'd our ignorance and put bias to an end.
Monday, May 4, 2015
Privilege isn't usually isolated, many times, certain kinds of privilege are connected to others. White privilege, for example, connects to class privilege in many cases.This article breaks down information from the US Census Bureau and provides six easy-to-understand charts that illustrate six different building blocks in the bridge between white and class privilege.
See the full story on Upworthy.com
Sunday, March 29, 2015
Last week I came across an article arguing that the word "thug" is the new "n----r."
Could this be true?
This Friday I also had the privilege of sitting in on a high school presentation of Dr. Neal Lester's "Straight Talk about the N-Word." During which, he talked about the connotations of the N-word throughout history, and why it is considered to be so offensive.
I learned that not only was it a word to express hate, but it was often just a commonplace word to describe African Americans. In early 20th Century pop culture, the n-word was usually paired with derogatory statements, pictures, or lyrics. The n-word wasn't just something people randomly yelled when they wanted to hurt African Americans (although it was frequently used for that purpose as well). It was a word used to demean and categorize a whole subgroup of people on a day-to-day basis.
I had already read the article before I went to this presentation, and as I listened, I thought of the similarities between "thug" today and "n-----" in the past.
"Thug" is a word used far too often to describe African Americans. Every time we see a black victim of violence, the media is always trying to justify their attacks by trying to prove they are "thugs." And what exactly is a "thug?" What does one have to do to be considered a "thug?" The answer depends on who you ask, but to get a basic idea, I looked it up on Google images. Here's what came up:
Notice anything they all have in common?
These are the over exaggerated images that come to mind when somebody tries to imagine a thug. Like the n-word, "thug" is a word encompassing a negative connotation, perpetuating the mistreatment of African Americans that is used in a commonplace context. Because of this, I am entirely behind the idea that "thug" shares nearly identical implications with the n-word.
Is "thug" the new "n-----r?" It could be, it's used just as commonly to say something very similar, but that's just my opinion. What are your thoughts?
Sunday, March 8, 2015
This Buzzfeed article has been trending for a while, and I've felt the need to share it since the first time I came across it. José's story is as shocking as it is tragic. Most importantly, it is representative of the unconscious bias that many of us have.
It is unlikely that each one of the hundreds of employers José contacted consciously decided not to hire him because he had a Hispanic name. Scenarios like this happen all the time due to an unconscious bias perpetuated by the stereotypes associated with members of each race. John, Joe, or George are perceived as more professional than Juan, José, or Jorge because employers often associate ethnic names with the stigma of an ethnicity. In José's case, he was assumed to be a migrant worker, and immediately dismissed. Bias, whether conscious or unconscious, hurts people all the same. It's important to be aware of the different kinds of bias so that we can try to identify them in ourselves and others, and then fix the problem from there.
Sunday, February 1, 2015
Earlier this week Disney released its design for their first Latina princess ever. Corks were blown off of campaign bottles, parades filled the streets, and the media celebrated this leap in pop culture diversity. All for basically no reason at all. The initial problem here is that we are waaay past due for a Hispanic princess; however, there are enough flaws with Elena of Avalor that Disney should consider going back to the drawing board with this one.
The special irony here is that just like Latinos in the real world, Elena too is being marginalized in her land far far away. Unlike the first Arabic princess, the first African American princess, or the abundance of white princesses Disney has released, Elena's debut will not be on the silver screen, but on the children's show Sophia the First. Sadly, Elena is nothing more than a supporting role in a show where her appearance is likely going to be swept under the rug and forgotten.
Also, in a statement made by a senior vice president of Disney Junior, Nancy Kanter, it was revealed that "All [Sophia] characters come from fantasy lands that may reflect elements of various cultures and ethnicities but none are meant to specifically represent those real world cultures." Meaning, the actual culture of Latin Americans will not be represented along with Elena, which is arguably what gives the introduction of the character purpose. It isn't about the quotas or the skin color, but the accurate representation of individuals who are being underrepresented in society. When it comes to this standard, Disney is completely missing the mark.
There has been talk about Elena getting her own spinoff series in 2016, there is still room to be pessimistic. After all, it is very likely that creation was not a part of the original Sophia blueprints, but to rectify a PR mishap when Disney Junior originally announced Sophia the First and producers labeled the series's obviously Caucasian main character, Sophia as Latina. Whatever the case is, the introduction of Elena is far from the break through that it is being presented as. Yes, it is great that Hispanic children will be presented with a character that they can finally relate to at 9:30 am/8:30c, but will Elena dolls get a spot on Disney Store shelves? Will there be Princess Elena Halloween costumes, lunch boxes, or backpacks? Will there be a Princess Elena at Disneyland? The answer to all of these questions, more than likely, will be no. So why should we be celebrating this as a victory?The bigger question is, what does this have to do with privilege?

As one of my girls began to show off the princess sticker book she got for Christmas, she made a remark that there were no big stickers of Princess Tiana and seemed deeply disappointed by this. Children can sense these disparities early on. According to an "animation census" released by Buzzfeed 71.% of Disney Princesses are Caucasian.
White children are given a mass of princesses they can look to based on the loose argument that most fairy tales are based off of European characters. Meanwhile, children of color continue to wait....and wait....and wait.
Disney needs to be more diverse. There's no doubt about that, but garlanding a minor character in a minor series is not going to cut it. I say go big or go home. Anything that falls short of "big" this late in the game in unacceptable. Here's to hoping Disney, along with other animation studios, start to become more brave with their character designs and more accurate with the society they represent. None-white people are not make-believe, so we should really stop acting like it.
Sunday, January 18, 2015
This spoken word poem is proof that we are not beyond racism. The fact that people feel the need to act a specific way because of their race is not only heartbreaking, but shameful evidence that stereotypes affect people more than we think they do. Being smart or ignorant, cruel or kind, honest or dishonest are traits without color. Becoming who we are is never a matter of breaking or adhering to a stereotype. Many like to think this is common sense, but too many are caught unknowingly making assumptions about people they will never get to know. As this poem demonstrates, these assumptions are hurtful and contribute to the greater issue of racial bias that has been especially prevalent in recent events. If we were more mindful of the assumptions we made based on race, could we maybe see these negative effects dissipate? There is no straightforward answer, but it certainly is food for thought.
Sunday, January 11, 2015
The salience of racial inequality has been always been questioned, perhaps now more than ever. While people are still debating over whether or not racism still exists in a post-segregation era, there is something that most Americans can get behind when discussing racial bias: it's wrong. Call me optimistic, but I'd guess that if I were to pull 10 people from my neighborhood aside and ask them if they thought it was okay to be a racist, they'd probably say no. In a post-slavery, post-segregation society, we know that it is socially unacceptable to judge people based on their nationality, ethnicity, or the color of their skin. We've got it. Racism is bad.
Well, sometimes racism is bad.
There is good racism. Apparently.
Call me pessimistic,but I'd have to say that if I were to pull 10 people from my neighborhood aside and ask them to lay out both of their hands, I would still not have enough fingers to count the number of times that I have heard somebody make an argument for "good racism." Granted, it's never called racism, but it's the same concept. Racism is defined as,"the belief that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race." As said before, most people consider it morally wrong to make these judgements to say that somebody is dirty, inferior or dangerous, but what about smart? What about being frugal or athletic? Is it wrong to assume good things about people because of their race? To be blunt, yes. All bias is harmful.
For example, the concept that Asians are smart is one of the most common forms of "good" racism or "good" bias. Most people would consider that an advantage, but check out this. Clearly being seen as superior in a certain field is not always an advantage. Even if it was, this judge. ment is still wrong because it assumes that others are inferior to one's ability because they are of a different race. It doesn't matter the ethnicity of who's getting discriminated against: black, white, Indian, Asian. Judging one's abilities and granting them opportunities based off of anything other than their performance is unfair, no exceptions.
All bias is bad bias. All bias needs to end.
Sunday, December 7, 2014
Confession: I am a huge nerd. So, of course, when I heard there was going to be a new Star Wars movie, I just about ripped my hair out in excitement.Last week, the first trailer for Star Wars: The Force Awakens was released and with it came an explosion of questions, comments and concerns from the Star Wars fan base. Everything seemed to be going great and then...the bigots joined the party.Within minutes of the trailer's release outraged tweets from fans began to surface. Their biggest complaint : the casting of John Boyega, who is shown as a stormtrooper in the first 3 seconds of the clip. What was wrong with him? Well, he was black. Here are some quotes from a couple of gems I'd found:
" The new Star Wars trailer... I'm calm... "There has been an awakening, have you felt it..?" IT'S A BLACK GUY STORMTROOPER, OMFG Whaaaaaat?! "
"A black stormtrooper? THANKS, OBAMA"
AND
"How about the stormtrooper who just realized he became the third black guy in the galaxy?"
Most people were upset by the concept of a black stormtrooper because, in their opinion, it interferes with the accuracy of the new movie. In the original trilogy, it has been stated that all stormtroopers are clones of Jango Fett, bounty hunter and father of Boba Fett. If that's the case, all the stormtroopers should be white, right?
Well, no. Clone troopers were what made the original stormtrooper corps, By the time of the Second Imperial Civil War, well over a century since the fall of the original Empire, the vast majority of stormtroopers were composed primarily of enlisted soldiers. This opens the possibility of all kinds of diversity within the corps, not only in race, but species.
Secondly, the guy who plays Jango Fett, Temuera Morrison, isn't even white. As a recent article in The Atlantic points out, "he's a New Zealand born person of brown skin an Maori descent."
So, the argument that John Boyega doesn't belong on the cast of The Force Awakens is supported by no concrete evidence whatsoever.
It's just racist.
I feel that the Boyega controversy holds a couple of profound implications about society.
For example one of the main issues people said they had with the controversy was the media's reactions to the reactions of the star wars fan base. Many claimed that this scenario was just another example how people tend to jump the gun on calling things "racist." I have heard more conservative friends of mine make similar comments after similar stories hit the national radar. It's like we're searching for a problem, they say.
First of all, complaining about a cast member solely on the basis of their race is, by definition, racist. Nobody complained about the stormtrooper not looking like Jengo Fett, which just may have been a more reasonable complaint, they asked why he was black if the original face for the stormtroopers was white. Some even lamented that Boyega's casting was just another example of how Hollywood's newfound love for political correctness is ruining movies. This is not only incorrect (Hollywood is still extraordinarily white washed) but once again, racist. And yet, one week later, as I go through the comments on articles about the Boyega controversy, I see people defending these comments as innocent concerns from a passionate fanbase. I see accusations of people failing to see the "bigger picture." Well, there definitely is a bigger picture to be seen here, but anybody who is making excuses for these comments is holding the picture upside down.
We like to say that by 2014 racism cannot possibly exist and therefore anybody accusing anybody of racist remarks is over-sensitive, too liberal or obsessed with political correctness. If the events and protests within the last couple of weeks have spelled anything out, it is that this is simply not true. When the public cries out over this breed of uproar, be it as shocking as Ferguson or a simple as a bigoted response to a movie trailer, and we as a society respond by saying that it's all just a big soap box over nothing we are sweeping the bigger issue under the rug.
This nonchalant response not only causes people to ignore these bigger issues, it causes them to normalize the behavior that goes hand and hand with it. "Yes, some police officers are guilty of racial profiling. That doesn't mean we need to reform the system." "Yes, there are some racists online, but if we ignore them, their voice doesn't really matter." Simple statements like these may seem harmless, but in reality, they enable a kind of mentality that is toxic to our social ecosystem. Normalizing or dismissing bias allows for it to be embedded in our culture.
Since the trailer's release, John Boyega released a statement to the critics of his casting by telling them to "get used to it." A simple but powerful response; however, when it comes to racism in our own community we should defiantly not get used to it. We should speak out and make it clear that this kind of behavior is nowhere near acceptable.Awareness may not solve racism entirely, but it will prevent ourselves from making the problem any worse than it already is.
And really, that is the very least we can do.
Thursday, November 27, 2014
Last week, someone showed me this article. It talks about how some students spoke up about the University of Chicago’s “culture of racial intolerance”. Colleges aren't the safest community for people of color, but when people spoke out against this racial intolerance they were subjected to slurs, and violence, and threats of harm and rape. And frankly, that's appalling. The university said that the threats were “unacceptable” and notified law enforcement. But the students say it isn't enough.
Students, daily, are subject to these threats all around the country because they want to see the culture of their school be more accepting. And as spokespeople, they should be looked up to and respected. Not threatened to the point where they don’t leave their homes. To think that threats of rape was a person’s reaction to another students asking for diversity is, to me, frightening. All students have the right to feel safe.
I've rarely have dealt with racism first hand. I’m white passing and go to school in a safe community. But not all people do. Some people have to worry about their safety every day, just because of their skin color. That is something that I will never really understand, but I can understand the harm it places another person in. And a person’s identity is not something to be “tolerated”, but accepted. The culture of a school shouldn't be “tolerant” of people of color, but welcoming. Food for thought.
Sunday, November 23, 2014
This morning, Michael Eric Dyson, a professor of sociology at Georgetown University and former mayor of New York City, Rudy Giuliani got into an argument that was so heated I probably could have fried an egg on the laptop I was watching it from. Tonight's post was supposed to be on the disproportion of global access to a quality education; however, when I came across this video it felt like I was struck by lightening. I had to write my comment down: Rudy Giuliani's assertion that law enforcement needs to crack down on black offenders more than racial discrimination is not only ridiculous but down right offensive. I was disgusted by the ignorance of his comment.
The video was short, but the few words that were exchanged between the two men seemed to be enough to completely mirror a conflict in our communities' streets right before my very eyes. If the events of past two years have taught us anything it's that racial discrimination is a societal plague that has yet to be cured and that has proven to be fatal. We'd like to believe that by 2014, bigotry like this has been eradicated, and that's why we like to make excuses as Mr. Giuliani did when he said that the real problem lies within the races themselves. Unfortunately, this kind of mentality only furthers society away from progress. Pointing fingers in the wrong direction only enables the issue to continue as is.
Throughout the interview, Mr. Giuliani continued to stress the statistic that 93% of black victims of violence are attacked by offenders of the same race. Sure, with a figure like that, it's easy to say that white offenders aren't the issue here, but that's completely missing the point. Nobody is implying that white offenders are the issue. Nobody is suggesting that there's been a new-age serge of white supremacists killing off African American teens. To me these are the only claims where yes, the statistic that 93% of black victims of violence are attacked by offenders of the same race proves to be an effective use of devil's advocate.
However, this is not the case. The root of the problem is not white police officers, it's society's tendency to hold onto racial stereotypes.
I feel like too many people live in this bubble where the racism that exists is directly proportionate to the racism that they see. I know I'm one of those people. It's 2014, I know that there are good people and bad people, criminals and law abiding citizens and criminals, and that these qualities in a person should never be seen as directly associated with race. Because of this, I just assume that racial profiling is a tendency isolated in a few people. This past Monday, I came across a rude awakening when this link was shared in a thread over Gmail. It shows the proportion of arrest rates of black and non-black citizens in various American cities Orange dots represent zero disparity between black and non-black arrests, green represent small disparities, and blue represent large disparities.
Here's a map of the country:
Here's Ferguson:
Here's Mesa, Arizona:
I was shocked when I saw these maps. I have spent my whole life thinking that my community was immune to racial profiling, but the opposite has proved to be true. It seems that the same concept applies to the rest of the country as well. My take on this is that in some cases a disparity makes sense. For example, if a city's population is predominately black, then of course the black arrest rate will be the highest. For a country where African Americans make up only 14% of the population, this map is overwhelmingly blue and green. As I watched the NBC Newsroom debate on violence in black communities, my thoughts went back to these pictures. Mr. Giuliani says that racial profiling isn't what's causing all of this turmoil, that rather the problem is isolated in black communities alone. But they numbers, they speak for themselves.
Mr. Giuliani's comments scare me because he is one voice that represents millions. There are people out there who see this map and will tell themselves that every single one of these arrests was sensible and justified, who will argue statistic after statistic on minority incarceration and recidivism before they consider that maybe the crimes weren't committed by the ones being arrested. I'd say that we all know at least five off the top of our heads. This mentality is toxic to our communities. Saying that the solution to black victimization is cracking down on interracial violence is like trying to get rid of a weed by pulling of a couple of its leaves. Sure, it's a part of the problem, but that weed is going to stay where it is and grow more and more until it is pulled out roots and all.
Mr. Giuliani's comment is a wake up call if anything. Yes, it is 2014 but people will still believe what they want to. The question is, what do we do about it? Do we try to convince them otherwise or do we just leave the bigots behind in the movement?
I believe that a bit of the problem lies in all of us, whether it's because of ignorance, or a lack of motivation to cure it. It's up to everyone to help be the change by finding the source of the problems and tackling it head on, even if putting the blame elsewhere is easier to do. The first step is accepting responsibility, then possibility and then moving forward from there.
Monday, November 17, 2014
I came across this picture a couple of months ago online and I thought it was priceless. Not priceless as in hilarious, just...invaluably accurate. Although, not all of us are circles.This, of course isn't just limited to circles, I'm sure further down the wall there were some triangle holes and square holes, maybe even some nonagonal holes, but the point is, it takes a certain quality to get past certain "walls."
These qualities are what we call privilege. Unlike in this picture, it isn't so blatantly obvious who has what privilege, but I believe that it boils down the concept of privilege and some basic no no's pretty well.
Insisting something is easy is one of the worst ways that we can impose our privilege on others. Sometimes, it doesn't matter how hard you work or how confident in yourself you are. You will always be a triangle, and that hole will always be circular. There is nothing more aggrivating than having somebody insist that, regardless of your qualities or the issues you face in your life, you have the ability to simply walk through any obstacle in life as if they were tailor made to let you pass. It's like saying every person in every financial situation can afford to buy a house, or that anybody can get married without any issues, or that under every employer equal work means equal pay. None of these are true, but so many times we find ourselves slipping up by assuming that things are as easy for everyone else as they are for us.
Be mindful of who you are and what you say to others, because the cruel reality is that we don't have equal opportunity across the board. That's the basic concept of privilege.
Sometimes that's a little hard to get, but I feel as if this comic does a really great job of simplifying it so I had to share.
Thoughts?
Friday, November 14, 2014
Teaching WEB DuBois’ The Souls of Black Folk (1903) last night to my undergrads at ASU, I was reminded that the context of that piece and his rival Booker T. Washington’s Up from Slavery is really white privilege, about what to do with blacks just freed from slavery. While DuBois asks the perennial question at the turn of the century—How do we measure progress?—the question is really one that begs a critical examination of American racism that will show its head no matter how much hall sweeping and brick building Booker T. recommends that free backs do to demonstrate their worth and usefulness.
To acknowledge that racism in America exists is to inherently recognize that whiteness has long been the unchallenged and unproven mark of beauty, achievement, morality and accomplishment. While Booker T. may be practicing his trickster skills in order to persuade/ seduce his rich white supporters to contribute significant funding to begin and keep open the historical Tuskegee Institute in Alabama, DuBois refused to accept that kind of soul-selling of blacks, offering instead a real plan for self-reliance intellectually and philosophically, albeit an elitist perspective.
My personal connection with the DuBoisian philosophy acknowledges that depending on someone to approve your actions or you is counter to the argument about self-reliance racially, socially, and politically.
Tuesday, October 21, 2014
My mother is a woman of many words. Many repeated words, actually. And it's ironic that her daughter, of all people, writes on a blog about privilege because if I were to make a guess, I'd say her top words are (next to "Chicana") rich, white, and privilege. And just to clarify for those who aren't living in Mesa, Arizona, these three words are basically interchangeable. The members of this community are, for the most part, very affluent and predominately white. As a Hispanic family who struggles to keep above the poverty line, the members of my household are, on paper, a clear minority. Off paper, when it comes to my sisters and I, not so much, but we'll dive more into this one another week. For now, the focus is my mother who, over the years, I have discovered an overwhelming bitterness in, especially for the rich, white members of our community.
It's through this bitterness that "privilege" was introduced to me as a dirty word. After my parents divorced, I was taught that we were fighting against every light skinned, nicely dressed lady I bumped into on the street because it is the privileged that are giving us dirty looks, the privileged cutting us off in the school parking lot, the privileged taking all of the good part-time jobs, the scholarships, the everything-that-is-affordable just because they have the money to take what is theirs. Our lives were hard, but it was the privileged who were oppressing us. At least, that's what I was taught.
It's through this bitterness that "privilege" was introduced to me as a dirty word. After my parents divorced, I was taught that we were fighting against every light skinned, nicely dressed lady I bumped into on the street because it is the privileged that are giving us dirty looks, the privileged cutting us off in the school parking lot, the privileged taking all of the good part-time jobs, the scholarships, the everything-that-is-affordable just because they have the money to take what is theirs. Our lives were hard, but it was the privileged who were oppressing us. At least, that's what I was taught.
Is teaching your children that wrong? Yes.
And yet, it all feels completely justified. My mom is a Hispanic who grew up in Arizona, a part of a generation that forgot how to speak Spanish because their bilingual, bruised parents told them English was the only safe thing to speak. We moved to Mesa, Arizona proven to be the most conservative city in the U.S. in the heat of SB1070. Discrimination is not just the occasional supermarket bigot, it is something that fills the desert air, makes it thick and suffocates the minority. My mom knows that well enough to fully warrant her bitterness. And further, how can a woman, a mother, not feel bitter about her own financial crisis when her children are surrounded by a pool of students more comfortable than they ever could be? When MORE is a tangible, but untouchable reality swinging in front of her face on a a day-to-day basis?
The way she feels, it makes sense.
But is it right?
That is the question I am posing today. And my opinion is that, when it comes to Privilege Profiling, empathy is the only thing that can really be extended in this situation. I can understand why my mother says what she does, but that doesn't make it okay to say that my white friends are incapable of extending good manners because their "privlege parents" never taught them to. You don't have to be a fan of privilege. And if you don't have a godlike sense of patience for the privileged, that's okay too. However, letting your viewpoint on privilege affect the way you view and treat people with privilege is not okay.
Privilege is just another way that we are all different, and, as said before, differences are to de embraced.
But that's just my take on it.
What do you think?
Friday, September 19, 2014
Last night I had the honor of hearing Nikki Giovanni speak to
a crowd of about 1300 people at the Mesa Arts Center. Her talk was punctuated by numerous comments that were both humorous and insightful. Several of which
I’m sure I’ll be mulling over for many, many months. There was one thing she said though, that
brought me so much hope. Hope, is something I've
been struggling with lately.
Before Giovanni’s talk, I attended a private reception in her
honor. A colleague and I were discussing
how sometimes it feels as though things in the world are getting worse. Beheadings are becoming an almost weekly occurrence. In certain parts of the country, a black boy,
or even girl, who happens to be near someone with a gun is suddenly in grave
danger. The Ebola epidemic is growing at
an exponential rate and is showing no signs of slowing. Nearly 300 Nigerian school girls are still missing - probably being raped and tortured while we all go on with our lives.
My colleague and I wondered if it simply appeared that things were getting
worse because of advances in social media coupled with the 24 hour news
cycle. He put forth the idea that maybe a hyper focus
on certain new stories can actually perpetuate violence or wrong doing. By the time we finished our conversation and
got in line to get some food, a thoughtful, albeit weighty silence had come
over us.
Then we went to hear Giovanni speak. If you've never had the chance to hear her give a talk, find a way to do so before you die.
She is hilarious, dead serious, and full of innovative ideas for addressing global and local problems - all while never taking herself too seriously. She's an everyday woman who just happens to be armed to the tenacity to take on just about anything.
After giving her talk, she and Dr. Lester sat
on stage and he fielded questions from the audience and asked a few of his own
as well. One of the things he asked Giovanni was whether or not she thought we are losing our humanity. She was quick to joke that to ask whether or
not we’re losing our humanity assumed that we had some in the first place.
But after a few laughs she said something that brought me
such peace. She said that when people
are running a race and get to the point where they can see the finish line,
they often feel as if they should be running faster.
Since the finish is so close they begin to sense that maybe they should already
be there, that they should already have arrived.
For the most part, we can see the finish
line. Yes, there are people who still
hate homosexuals, Jews, people of color, and the like. However, those individuals have found themselves
living on the fringe of society. Most people
consider them to be extremists, disturbed, or grossly uninformed. No doubt, there is still a lot of work to do
in terms of bias, acceptance, and living in a world where people are not unsafe
or unaccepted simply because of who they choose to marry or how they choose to
love.
But most of us want to get there.
We can see the finish line.
Some people think we already crossed it and therefore just need
to stop talking about it. That's another post, but even in that dilemma there is hope. We want the same thing. We just disagree on how close we are to achieving it.
I do believe that we still have a ways to go, but I can see the finish line. Most of us can see the finish line. That is a far, far cry from where we were as
a nation just sixty years ago.
Thank you, Nikki Giovani, for reminding me that even though
we’re not there yet, we still have cause to celebrate.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Search
Popular Posts
-
This weekend everyone on my Facebook feed seemed to be up in arms over Jaden Smith wearing a dress to coachella. I don't really und...
-
Last week I came across an article arguing that the word "thug" is the new "n----r." Could this be true? This ...
-
In his comic "On a Plate," Auckland-based artist Toby Morris demonstrates both the effects and the ca...
Archive
Powered by Blogger.




